Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Simple attempt to compare D3S, D3X and D800E

RIW

Kings Lynn, UK
265 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author
RIW Silver Member Nikonian since 18th Jan 2009
Thu 13-Dec-12 05:51 PM

Hi!

I have been trying to understand my responses to pictures from the D3S, D3X and D800E. Not numbers but appearances. A kitchen experiment in bad weather. It is all trial and error so by posting my efforts I may get some really useful replies. I am hoping!

1 I created a trial target in Word of a table of 65 columns and 32 rows with 2.25 point lines and put in Arial bold 12 point letters and numbers. Laser prined on copy paper. Finer lines and letters were tried but though interesting, the images could not be reduced to show anything for posting. The whole sheet is shown in the attachment 1.

2 This was photographed at an angle of roughly 25 degrees to the horizontal. Mixed lighting in kitchen. Shown in attachment 2. (24 - 70 mm @ 24 mm so some distortion - the tripod was upright!) The distance was adjusted so that the width of the A4 target page exactly filled the image area halfway up the image. The sloping target reveals more about focus, resolution, depth of focus, focus shifts and field curvature over the whole image in one shot than a multitude of flat shots.

3 In these shots I used a Zeiss 100 mm f2 Macro lens. Focused at f2 in LV where available. Focus was on the upper half of the letters E in a central row. Exposure by IR remote, Mirror up. EV = +1.7. Auto WB. ISO 100, or 200 on D3S. Manual adjustment of aperture ring, as noted. RAW files.

4 Processed in PS6. ACR 7.1. Sliders mainly set to 0 with minimal sharpening. Saving the images for posting has lost a lot of detail, so I suggest if you are interested you make your own images to pixel peep. Beware this can be addictive!

5 Comparison images at f4, size reflecting pixel number. Attachment 3 - D3S, Attachment 4 - D3X, Attachment 5 - D800E. I could not composite them and save as a jpg. Brain failure of some kind. Attachment 6 is the three scaled to the same image magnification and composited.

THE DIFFERENCES BETWEEN THE IMAGES ARE MUCH LESS THAN I EXPECTED.

6 The next attempt was an aperture series with the D800E. The lens was stopped down between exposures of f2 to f22. No other changes made. Central slices of the images are composited in Attachment 7. f4 is the blackest image of the E, but the in focus plane is painfully shallow. The increasing diffraction softening from f5.6 and increasing depth of 'focus' to f22 is clear. Note this lens has no focus shift. Some other lenses tried had focus shift that wandered back or forwards up to 4 rows of letters by f8, leaving the primary row of Es out of focus even with the increasing depth of focus.

7 Not illustrated, because I am not posting lens comparisons, I looked at the aperture series of a number of prime lenses from f2 (or f2.8) to f8 right across the image. The following were revealed: that flat field lenses have the row of Es in focus across the sheet even at f2. That some lenses never focus at the edges. That any field curvature shows up as the line of focus curving up or down towards the edges. Most illuminating on some very expensive lenses! That focus shift was frequently found, varied with aperture, and was sometimes severe. It will cripple performance of affected lenses if they are not focussed stopped down in LV, or AF fine tune is not adjusted at the aperture that will be used, so it is important to know which lenses have it.

I hope this is not considered too long, but if it is the moderators should remove it.

Roderick



Click on image to view larger version



Click on image to view larger version



Click on image to view larger version



Click on image to view larger version



Click on image to view larger version



Click on image to view larger version



Click on image to view larger version


Attachment#1 (jpg file)
Attachment#2 (jpg file)
Attachment#3 (jpg file)
Attachment#4 (jpg file)
Attachment#5 (jpg file)
Attachment#6 (jpg file)
Attachment#7 (jpg file)

Visit my Nikonians gallery.

G