Any one have experience with Tamron 11-18? I want to know if this is a good alternative to the Sigma 10-20. Thank You
#2. "RE: Tamron wide angle 11-18" | In response to Reply # 0twanto Basic MemberSun 20-Nov-05 12:59 PM
I have done some brief comparisons at a store for a few test shots from both of these lenses. My "tests" were far from scientific, but from my point of view the image quality of both lenses was quite close. It some cases the Tamron looked sharper and exhibited less CA than the Sigma, and in other cases it was the other way around. I ended up not being able to make a choice. If I were going to buy one, I would redo my test shots. So, take my experience with a grain of salt.
I also comapred the Sigma to the Tokina 12-24 and found that the Tokina was REALLY bad at controlling CA on my D70. Again, this was just an informal in-store test.
#3. "Maybe these will help" | In response to Reply # 0cameraguy21773 Registered since 08th Sep 2004Mon 21-Nov-05 10:08 AM
Handheld and ver informal.
Take Only Pictures, Leave Only Footprints
Visit my Nikonians gallery.