D1x users: Raw or jpeg fine?
I find the D1x raw files have noise above about ISO 250 if the lighting is even somewhat shadowy. And it gets progressively more intense with each 1/3 stop higher ISO. By ISO 800, the image has lost its sharpness and looks somwhat mushy. The D1H does not exhibit this softness until you go to the Hi settings of 3200 and above.
Now, I'm a strictly raw shooter, because I believe in having the absolute best image quality.
But recently I tried the camera out in jpeg fine, medium resolution mode (2,000 x 1,312 res.). I was shooting an event at night without flash at ISO 800 under stadium lights. And low and behold, the images at ISO 800 in jpeg are spectacular. They seem every bit as good as those from the D1H. I haven't tried the large jpeg fine yet, so I don't know if there's a difference between large and medium in terms of image quality/noise levels.
Like I said, I'm a raw shooter, and will only shoot jpeg when I'm doing freelance jobs that require uploads to a website. For my own photography, I prefer raw. But I'll be damned if I could produce quality as good as the in-camera jpeg processing. I don't think I can. Raw format is noisier and that's a fact.
Anyone else have similar experiences? Which image format do you prefer?
Nikon user since 2000
#1. "RE: D1x users: Raw or jpeg fine?" | In response to Reply # 0jimbojones1954 Registered since 21st Oct 2009Fri 23-Oct-09 09:48 PM
I have had a plain D1 since 2001 and I stopped shooting in raw format a few years ago. I didn't run into the same issues you did with the picture noise, but over time I realized I was hard pressed to tell the difference between raw and JPEG fine images.
I'm sure there will be nit-pickers who will say go raw, but I do get three times the images per card, and I have 30" x 45" enlargements to prove how good the JPEG quality of the D1 is. All this from a "measly" 2.7 megapixels...
My advice? Go with you eyes and your gut. If JPEG works for you, God bless and go forward. For me, if I shoot an assignment where the client demands raw files, then I shoot raw. If not, I go JPEG fine.
Hope this helps.
P.S. If you have an issue with rubber parts coming off the camera as I did, Perfect Glue #2 is unbeatable.
Visit my Nikonians gallery.