Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference


This topic is locked. This message is locked.
tvalleau

Marina, US
23 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author
tvalleau Registered since 18th Jul 2011
Tue 11-Dec-12 10:56 PM

After taking a few shots with my D600 kit lens, the 28-300, I became suspicious, and just now ran a few fairly careful tests. Mirror lockup; IR remote; tripod etc.

The test was the same shot with and without a (fairly expensive) B+W UV-1 filter.

boy howdy! The shots taken with the filter on were all more soft than those without it. I didn't have to strain to see the difference.

Now: have I just been shooting so long with a protective filter on my lenses that I simply never noticed before? (If so, what caused my suspicion?)

Admittedly, I've not run this test on previous gear (D300, D7000) but then I never felt that the images were less than they should be either.

So, perhaps a bad filter, although visually, it looks OK.

I'm just wondering if the gyrations it takes to make a zoom with the range of this lens means that it really doesn't want any extra glass hanging off the front.

In short: has anyone else seen this? Run a similar test with their own copy of this lens?

I'd much rather clean a filter than the front element of a lens, but not if that filter is going to crimp the quality, of course.

Comments appreciated.

OH... a PS - is the front element of modern lenses more scratch resistant than they were 20-30 years ago?

Thanks folks.

my website

Subject
ID
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
1
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
2
     Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
3
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
4
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
5
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
6
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
7
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
8
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
9
     Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
10
     Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
11
          Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
12
               Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
14
     Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
15
          Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
17
               Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
18
                    Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
21
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
13
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
16
     Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
19
          Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
20
               Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
22
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
23
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
24
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
25
     Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
26
     Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
27
          Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
28
     Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
32
          Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
33
               Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
34
                    Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
35
                         Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
38
                              Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
39
                              Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
42
                                   Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
43
                                        Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
44
                                        Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
45
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
29
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
30
     Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
31
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
36
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
37
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
40
Reply message RE: 28-300 w & w/o filter - big difference
41

G