Has anyone experienced this when using NX2. When I apply sharpening the photo initially looks great then a few seconds later it just softens like the sharpening was removed or turned down. I have to deleted the step and redo, at times this will work and the sharpening remains sometimes it will soften again. This just started today. There have been no changes to the computer.
This is really annoying, since I cannot feel confident that my adjustments will remain active.
I was using v 2.2.5 I did a complete uninstall and reverted back to v 2.2.4 still have the same issue. I have looked for possible settings that may need to be adjusted but have not found anything that relates. I really like NX2 for its ease of use but if this continues I'm going to be forced to move to something else.
OK then do a search here because I know this was discussed a few months ago in the forum, but I don't remember the outcome. I have never seen this, and my images sharpen just fine. I am on a PC, not a MAC.
It appears the search feature is not working. Any search I do no matter the subject returns 0 entries.
Edited: All of the search requests come back with 0 entries, however, some have a link in red titled "did you mean..." if you click on that it will list the entries. However the intial search doesn't work and not all search requests have the "did you mean" link.
I was never able to get any hits at all in any of the post-processing sub-forums via NikoScope, even if I simply selected the forum and searched without any keywords. Bo and JRP have both verified that there is a bug in the thread I referenced earlier.
Did they fix the bug then? I do agree that I should have received a hit for the current thread because it spoke of sparpening going soft, but I did not. In any search engine, what you enter can make a big difference, but I do think Bing does a very good job of figuring out what I am looking for.
As far as I know, they are still trying to figure out why the sub-forums are not getting indexed. I wonder if people would have voted for the split post-processing forums if they had known they were giving up search. (Sorry, but I'm still annoyed by the new structure.)
I entered "nx2 sharpening" in the Search Box at the top of this thread; "nx2 sharpening forumId:"133"" was returned in the Search Box on the next page with zero results. Then, I deleted the "forumid:"133" part of the phrase, re-clicked on Search and many responses were returned. So, Nikkoscope works, albeit with an extra step.
I would have voted for it anyway. Discrete forums is much better for finding information. NIkonscope isn't that important to me. It'd be nice if they fixed it, but I find most search engines are 50% useful, at best.
I guess I completely missed when the PP forums split. But having found the "new" forum I have subscribed to everything in the entire forum. I feel like a kid in the candy store with many fine tips gleaned in the last week or so from Danny, Bob, and others. Thanks so far guys!!
This happens to me almost all the time. I'm not sure whether to assume the sharpening was applied and the rendering is wrong or what. I've seen this discussed before and somebody suggested looking at the image at 100%. I'll have to experiment with this some more when I have time. I wonder if anybody has ever reported it to Nikon.
I agree, it is hard to feel confident that the sharpening took. Worse, you can't really determine if the sharpening is appropriate because it doesn't stay visible long enough to make changes.
I did a test last night. I processed a photo and then applied sharpening (At 100% view). I then switch to fit to screen, for the few seconds after switching views the sharpening was visible it appeared to be adequate then it smoothed out. I saved the NEF and closed NX2. I then opened the NEF in FastStone Image Viewer and was shocked to see that the photo looked over sharpened. It did not look like the sharpened version in NX2 even though it was only visible for a second or two. I then checked the smooth box in FastStone and the image appeared like the one in NX2 after it changed from displaying the sharpening to the less sharpened version that remained on the screen. I doubled checked NX2 settings to make sure there wasn't a setting for smoothing and there was none.
What concerns me more now is that the sharpening that appears adequate in NX2 appears over sharpened in FastStone. These little annoyances really impact the efficiency of the application but worse I feel I can't trust the settings. I like NX2 for the simplicity of use and when it works it processes NEFs well but these issues may force me in another direction.
this is something i've noticed since i first began using nx2 and has persisted across computers. my sense has been that what i am seeing is just millions of pixels as they go through wave after wave of processing to the final result...in terms of the printed image, the result has always mirrored my monitor...(i remember when i first began using nx2, that, as the first wave of processing went on, i thought, i like that level of sharpening, only to discover that as the next wave came through, it would change as you describe, and so, i'd have to do more porocessing....) i can't explain the appearance in your other programs - i comfort myself with the fact that the printed results mirror my monitor work...so, how does your printing go?? mark www.broadwallphotography.com
Fri 10-Sep-10 10:58 PM | edited Sat 11-Sep-10 02:00 PM by jacsr
Thanks for the link. I tried the settings suggested and still no joy. However, I did discover something. I decided to go back and check my processing steps. What I did find was for the photos that I have been experiencing this softening, I had forgotten to remove the initial capture sharpening. I removed the capture sharpening, waited for the update to complete, then adjusted the USM in 100% view and waited for the adjustment to complete. In fact I waited a full 5 minutes to see if it would smooth and it did not. I then set the view to Fit To Screen and it remained stable no smoothing. I saved the NEF, and then opened it in FastStone viewer and the photo looked as it did in the Fit to Screen view in NX2.
I don't know why the capture sharpening would cause the softening like it did but for now it seems to be working. I will keep testing to see if it remains stable.
Ok, it is official, at least in my case. If I leave the capture sharpening enabled the picture will soften after applying output sharpening at the end. If I turn the capture sharpening to "0" and apply output sharpening the picture remains sharp. I tested this theory while processing 50 nefs and I was able to reproduce the affect consistently.
I cannot figure out why this would happen but I guess it really doesn't matter as long as I know what can keep it from happening. In any event, so far removing capture sharpening resolves the issue I am having.
Can you please explain exactly what you mean by "capture sharpening"? Do you mean the sharpening that can be done with the Picture Control in the Develop section? Some people apply a light unsharp mask edit step as capture sharpening.
If you can verify that it is repeatable, it might be worthwhile reporting the problem to Nikon. Although, I've learned not to hope for much when you report software problems to Nikon.
>Can you please explain exactly what you mean by "capture >sharpening"? Do you mean the sharpening that can be done >with the Picture Control in the Develop section? Some people >apply a light unsharp mask edit step as capture sharpening. > >If you can verify that it is repeatable, it might be >worthwhile reporting the problem to Nikon. Although, I've >learned not to hope for much when you report software problems >to Nikon. > >Danny >>size="2"]A Nikonian in North Carolina
Yes each of the picture controls have a default sharpening setting, if I leave the default picture control sharpening in place then add USM, the photo will appear sharp for a second or two and then soften. If I remove the picture control default sharpening (set to 0) the photo will remain sharp after USM has been applied.
I have submitted this to Nikon, but as you say I'm not holding my breath for a reply.
so, if you have sharpening set in camera and then in the 'camera settings' step, you remove sharpening (set to '0') in nx2 do you observe the same finding after adding usm? mark www.broadwallphotography.com