Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Regret purchasing D600 vs D800

dagoldst

Little Rock, US
3076 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800"

dagoldst Gold Member Nikonian since 02nd Dec 2012
Tue 04-Jun-13 11:59 AM | edited Tue 04-Jun-13 12:09 PM by dagoldst

>Bengt says: "Shooting with D800e and a stellar prime you
>will experience changing times."

I get that you like your D800E. But it would be inaccurate to say that the D800E image quality is vastly superior. Lets consider.

1.The D800 offers around 19% more resolution that gives it a native print resolution of 24 inches. The D600 has a native print resolution of 20 inches. That's all the advantage, (this is at 300 dpi). If one printed side by side images at 24x36 inches, the pictures would be virtually identical.

2.The D800E can eke out a sharper image without post process sharpening. So can a D7100. It comes with a price of moire in some shots, but we'll put that issue to the side.

3. Both cameras have 14 bit color depth. The D800 can do uncompressed RAW, but in practical terms, the lossless compressed NEF format is not throwing away any data, so I can't see anything other than a larger file being written to a memory card. Not really an advantage I would think. Their ISO ranges are identical and the D800E gets a very slightly better DXOMark score, (and these are the two top cameras in the WORLD for image quality).

3. Every single stellar lens you can mount on a D800 can be mounted on a D600 - advantage? None. Besides, virtually every Nikkor in recent years produces stellar, sharp images when stopped down so primes only come into play shooting wide open and when one needs a fast lens - I am well aware of this, I own lots of primes from my film shooting days that still get used all the time.

So, yes, the D800E is a slightly advantaged camera, but in the right hands, nobody without a loupe and high level of expertise can tell whether a print was taken with a D600 or D800.

For reference on DXOmark numbers, sorry for the broke link, just copy into your browser, it will still get you there.

www.dxomark.com/index.php/Cameras/Compare-Camera-Sensors/Compare-cameras-side-by-side/%28appareil1%29/834|0/%28brand%29/Nikon/%28appareil2%29/814|0/%28brand2%29/Nikon


David

"Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof " - Carl Sagan

This is a hot, active topic! Regret purchasing D600 vs D800 [View all] , mickeyb48 Silver Member , Sat 01-Jun-13 12:45 AM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
1
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
2
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
3
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
5
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
6
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
14
          Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
15
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
4
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
7
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
10
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
18
          Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
19
               Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
20
                    Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
23
                    Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
24
                         Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
27
                              Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
28
                              Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
37
                    Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
26
                         Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
29
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
8
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
9
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
11
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
12
          Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
13
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
16
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
17
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
21
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
22
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
31
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
32
          Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
34
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
33
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
25
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
30
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
35
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
36
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
38
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
39
          Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
40
          Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
41
          Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
42
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
43
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
44
     Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
45
          Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
46
          Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
47
Reply message RE: Regret purchasing D600 vs D800
48