Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?

Ferguson

Cape Coral, US
5701 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?"

Ferguson Silver Member Fellow Ribbon awarded for the generous sharing of his high level expertise in the spirit of Nikonians Nikonian since 19th Aug 2004
Thu 17-Oct-13 03:30 PM


OK, trial #2. This is kind of interesting.

I set up a target on a driveway. Is it a good target -- don't know, but it's a pretty plain scene, the entire view (and I was on matrix metering if it matters -- I still don't know for sure). It was bright sun in a cloudless blue sky, so the light was very constant.

I took four shots each, just to confuse you (but really because I didn't swap cameras first) the D4 is on top, the D800 on the bottom:

Auto-1
Auto-2
Direct Sun
Force temp = 5000 K

Click on image to view larger version


The D800 looks warmer, and if you look at the histograms there is a pretty consistent red (and only red) shift:

Click on image to view larger version


At first I thought that one was more sensitive generally, and it was an exposure difference, but what I'm seeing is the D800 having more red, and less yellow from what is otherwise the same image (on auto, so it is perhaps shifting). These are from ViewNX by the way.

Adobe shows those two at (4400,-7 for D4) and (4750, +3 for D800).

Below is the histogram for the fixed "K" setting, where in theory the color rendering on conversion should be identical. They are closer, but they are not the same -- the red is shifted a bit higher on the D800. That's consistent throughout the shots.

Click on image to view larger version


It seems as though the sensor is actually more sensitive to red on the D800? Is that how to interpret this?

But perhaps NOT on the AF sensor, which sets the "auto" (and maybe a bit the reverse), so the result is auto is warmer?

And in warmer (lower temperature, oddly) light like incandescent it doesn't matter as much in some fashion?

I went back and looked at the indoor shots, though, and the red peaks are shifted right on the D800 there also, including on the fixed presents like incandescent.

Linwood

Comments welcomed on pictures: Http://www.captivephotons.com



Attachment#1 (jpg file)
Attachment#2 (jpg file)
Attachment#3 (jpg file)

This is a hot, active topic! Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere? [View all] , Ferguson Silver Member Fellow Ribbon awarded for the generous sharing of his high level expertise in the spirit of Nikonians , Sun 13-Oct-13 01:17 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
1
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
2
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
3
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
4
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
6
     Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
7
          Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
9
               Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
10
                    Reply message "RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?"
11
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
5
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
8
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
12
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
13
     Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
14
     Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
15
          Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
16
               Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
17
                    Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
18
                         Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
19
                              Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
21
                                   Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
22
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
20
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
25
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
23
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
24
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
26
     Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
27
          Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
28
               Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
29
                    Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
30
                    Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
31
                         Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
32
                              Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
33
                              Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
34
                                   Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
35
                                        Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
36
                                        Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
37
                                             Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
38
                                                  Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
39
                                                  Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
40
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
41
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
42
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
44
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
43
     Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
45
          Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
46
               Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
47
                    Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
48
                         Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
49
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
50
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
51
     Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
53
          Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
54
               Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
55
Reply message RE: Auto-White balance is off - setting somewhere?
52