Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application

PeterBeckett

Lincoln, US
835 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application"

PeterBeckett Gold Member Donor Ribbon awarded for his generous support to the Fundraising Campaign 2014 Nikonian since 04th Jan 2010
Sat 28-Jul-12 03:42 PM | edited Sat 28-Jul-12 04:57 PM by PeterBeckett

Hi Guys,
Due to my attention having to be focussed elsewhere for a while, I've done very little FoCal testing for the last few days. However, I did some yesterday - for a Pro photographer buddy who brought his D800 and several lenses to me for fine-tuning with his D800. In the hour before he arrived, I ran some Q&D tests to check that everything was working satisfactorily. A couple of those quick tests confirmed some suspicions that I had.

I believe I'm coming to the conclusion that the absolute numbers which FoCal calculates for each test may NOT be able to be used in an absolute sense. The numbers are affected by just too many factors. Actual illumination level of the target and how well the camera's WB matches the target illumination are just two of many.

Nevertheless, the QoF values CAN DEFINITELY be used to compare two lenses at identical settings and evaluated in reasonably quick succession using the same body. Likewise for the same lens on different bodies (as Larry has been doing). Also, I think I can say that FoCal produces very consistent optimal AFFT values for the same lens when the target is illuminated differently - even tho' the QoF values can be at substantially different levels.

When I get back to "serious" FoCal testing next week, I plan to focus on the effects of different target illumination on the absolute QoF numbers. Yesterday, I had the target in bright sunshine, and made comparative runs with/without an umbrella shading the direct sun from the target.

Please note, I am not criticising FoCal in any way by doubting its use for absolute sharpness evaluation. That's not a claim the developer makes. It's merely a hope that I had/have, and will continue to evaluate a little more. Nevertheless, it is looking as if it may be impractical to control all the test variables well enough for FoCal to be used in that role.

Pete

*** EDITED to provide a clarification ***
In para 3 above, when I talked about comparing two lenses, I should have made it clear that my experience relates to two different versions of the same lens. i.e., two different "vintages". Specifically, My own 70-200 is the earliest model that had VR. My buddy's version is absolutely up-to-date. I believe there was at least one other version released in-between these two. Comparative measurements reveal what appears to be a major optical improvement. VR was NOT enabled in either case. I hope I'm not shooting myself in the foot by sharing this extra comment, 'cos I shall be viciously attacking my piggy bank to fund an upgrade "soon". Therefore, my existing 70-200 will find itself on the IWTS forum in the not too distant future!

This is a hot, active topic! Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application [View all] , PeterBeckett Gold Member Donor Ribbon awarded for his generous support to the Fundraising Campaign 2014 , Wed 25-Jul-12 11:03 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
1
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
2
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
5
     Reply message ***Open Question...***
34
          Reply message RE: ***Open Question...***
35
               Reply message RE: ***Open Question...***
36
                    Reply message RE: ***Open Question...***
37
                         Reply message RE: ***Open Question...***
38
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
3
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
4
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
7
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
69
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
6
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
8
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
9
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
87
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
88
                         Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
89
                              Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
90
                                   Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
91
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
10
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
11
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
12
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
13
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
14
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
15
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
16
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
64
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
65
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
66
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
67
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
17
               Reply message Use of FoCal's QoF values in an absolute sense...
40
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
18
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
19
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
20
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
21
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
22
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
23
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
24
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
25
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
26
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
27
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
28
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
29
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
33
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
30
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
32
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
31
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
70
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
39
Reply message D800 vs. D4
41
Reply message RE: D800 vs. D4
42
Reply message RE: D800 vs. D4
43
Reply message RE: D800 vs. D4
44
Reply message RE: D800 vs. D4
45
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
46
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
47
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
48
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
49
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
51
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
50
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
52
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
54
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
56
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
57
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
60
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
53
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
55
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
58
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
59
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
61
                         Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
62
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
68
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
63
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
92
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
93
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
71
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
72
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
73
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
74
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
75
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
76
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
77
                         Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
78
                              Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
79
                              Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
82
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
80
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
81
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
83
                         Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
84
                              Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
85
                                   Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
86
                                        Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
94
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
95
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
96
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
97
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
98
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
99
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
102
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
103
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
106
                         Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
109
                         Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
111
                         Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
112
                              Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
113
                                   Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
114
                                        Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
115
                                             Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
116
                                             Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
117
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
100
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
101
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
104
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
105
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
107
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
108
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
110
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
118
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
119
                         Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
120
                              Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
121
                              Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
122
                              Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
123
                                   Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
124
                                   Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
126
                                        Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
127
                                        Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
128
                                             Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
129
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
130
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
131
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
132
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
133
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
134
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
135
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
137
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
136
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
138
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
139
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
140
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
141
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
142
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
143
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
144
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
145
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
146
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
147
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
148
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
149
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
150
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
154
                                                  Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
155
Reply message Reikan test on 70-200VR I and D800
151
Reply message RE: Reikan test on 70-200VR I and D800
152
     Reply message RE: Reikan test on 70-200VR I and D800
153
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
156
Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
157
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
158
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
159
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
160
     Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
161
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
162
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
164
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
165
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
166
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
167
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
173
          Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
168
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
170
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
171
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
175
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
172
               Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
174
                    Reply message RE: Testing of D800 with Reikan's FoCal application
176