Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Auto ISO and the D7000

agitater

Toronto, CA
4551 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: Auto ISO and the D7000"

agitater Gold Member Donor Ribbon awarded for his very generous support to the Fundraising Campaign 2014 Nikonian since 18th Jan 2007
Sun 29-May-11 11:03 PM | edited Mon 30-May-11 10:33 AM by agitater

>It's unfortunate, but it looks like financial gain may be
>influencing DPRs objectivity.

I think Stan's assessment (and his recounting of the Canon comparison issue) is dead on. But I think these sorts of problems result from a failure (or lack) of editorial supervision. When writers/reviewers aren't checked by an experienced editor, when writers/reviewers aren't vetted to eliminate obvious bias, when editorial policy is not clearly elucidated, and when obvious factual errors contained in reviews are not properly corrected (merely quietly amended later rather than broadcast or featured), DPR becomes less a reliable publication than just another busy blog and forum site.

Tech journalism was co-opted by advertising interests many years ago. Whatever objective agendas and policies existed in a few print publications (by no means the majority of them), died alongside the demise of print editions. Popular Photography is a great example of a mag that has always tested bodies and lenses quite rigorously (and despite arguments about its test methods - all methodologies contain flaws - at least PopPhoto tested in a consistent manner), but yet always found a way to enthusiastically trumpet almost every body and lens except for those real turkeys made by companies that would never be big advertisers in any event.

I've received so many complaints and counteractions from product makers (software and hardware) because of the "Cons" sections in my own reviews that I'm under no delusions about the relationship between difficulty getting review copies/models/items and a past review containing one too many Cons. This despite my transparent efforts to always keep my reviews as upbeat as possible. DPR, by contrast, has a much larger audience for its reviews and can level criticism (and does so) when it's appropriate. The problem is the basis for such criticism, and that's where a tough senior editor should be eliminating obvious bias in order to avoid obscuring practical review documentation and testing results.

Sites such as Nikonians may truly become the last bastions of collective objectivity when it comes to product assessments.

My Photo.Net Gallery
My Nikonians Gallery

Howard Carson

This is a hot, active topic! Auto ISO and the D7000 [View all] , danpass , Sun 05-Dec-10 01:57 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
1
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
2
     Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
4
     Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
6
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
12
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
13
     Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
5
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
7
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
11
                    Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
14
                         Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
17
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
3
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
8
     Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
9
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
10
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
15
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
16
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
18
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
20
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
21
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
19
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
22
     Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
23
     Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
24
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
25
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
32
     Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
26
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
27
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
28
                    Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
29
                         Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
30
                              Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
31
                                   Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
33
                                        Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
34
                                             Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
35
                                             Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
37
                                             Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
36
                                                  Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
38
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
39
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
40
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
41
Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
42
     Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
43
          Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
44
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
45
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
46
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
48
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
47
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
50
                    Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
51
                         Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
52
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
49
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
56
               Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
53
                    Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
54
                         Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
55
                              Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
57
                              Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
58
                              Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
59
                                   Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
60
                                        Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
61
                                        Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
62
                                             Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
63
                                             Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
64
                                             Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
65
                                             Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
66
                                        Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
67
                                             Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
68
                                                  Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
69
                                                  Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
70
                                                  Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
71
                                                  Reply message RE: Auto ISO and the D7000
72