Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Battery grip for D7100

doppler_fto

US
37 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: Battery grip for D7100"

doppler_fto Registered since 23rd Mar 2013
Thu 25-Apr-13 10:26 AM

vitalishe: The MB-D15 (like the MB-D10 before it) is made of Magnesium alloy. It is arguably better-built than the D7100 itself. See here:
http://www.photographyblog.com/news/nikon_d7100/

As for prices, I was referring to the MSRPs, where the MB-D10 is $330 versus $307 for the -D15. It's nice to know the street price for the -D10 is more reasonable.


ttc546, vitalishe: As far as the price, I'm pretty sure economy of scale has a large influence. Suppose that for every 100 D7100 buyers, there's 1 who also buys a vertical grip. That means that Nikon's MB-D15 line and supply chain will be running less efficiently than the analogous line and supply chain for the camera itself (imagine if they can fill a shipping container with cameras, but need to share containers for the grips, as one example — they incur extra handling costs just to combine shipments).

This isn't to say that the MB-D15 is more expensive than it should be; but rather that the D7100 is likely _less expensive_ than it would be if produced at the same volume as the MB-D15.

That said, is Nikon charging a hefty markup? I'm pretty sure the answer is "yes." Is that reasonable? I'm inclined to say "yes" also. Keep in mind that they need to recoup their design and development costs for the grip. (At the same time, this would be a good reason for them to figure out some way to share grips between bodies, although it's unclear what body it could share with in this case — there's nothing out there with a similar body size and shape. The D7100 is physically larger than the D7000, so the MB-D11 is right out.


That's also why I don't think it's fair to say "oh, a grip should cost $x00." Just like the value of a photographic print is more than the value of the paper, the value of a grip should be more than just the cost of its constituent parts. R&D, design, QA — it takes money to make a consistently good product. I think it'd be telling to see what the industry would come up with here if Nikon hadn't done most of the design and engineering for them.


Either way, to each their own.

------------------------------------------------------------
I make prints
  of moments
    that people love.

This is a hot, active topic! Battery grip for D7100 [View all] , vitalishe , Mon 22-Apr-13 06:46 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
1
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
2
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
3
     Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
4
          Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
7
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
5
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
6
     Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
9
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
8
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
10
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
11
     Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
12
          Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
13
               Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
14
                    Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
15
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
19
     Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
26
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
16
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
17
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
24
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
18
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
20
     Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
21
     Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
22
          Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
23
               Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
25
Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
27
     Reply message RE: Battery grip for D7100
28