Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

If not Lubricant…then what?


This topic is locked. This message is locked.
elec164

US
2598 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: If not Lubricant…then what?"

elec164 Silver Member Nikonian since 15th Jan 2009
Thu 22-Dec-11 06:53 PM | edited Thu 22-Dec-11 11:38 PM by elec164

>One of the reasons oil is not likely the cause is the range of
>spot size. None are large which would be expected if some
>mechanical throwing was involved, the spot size is constrained
>to a range of limited variability.

But the spots do vary in size and I think my enhanced (equalized and sharpened) example is not an accurate representation of the spots. I stopped being lazy and setup my two flash units on stands to properly expose the white paper instead of processing it to make it look better. This is a 100% crop of the bottom right corner (should be upper right looking into the mirror box from the front).

Click on image to view larger version



As you see the spots do vary in size and some are even irregular and not round. You make a good point in that I have a hard time wrapping my mind around how the mirror mechanism could sling oil back at the sensor. I provided the crop straight from the camera so you can view as you wish. I did a threshold adjustment on it and it really shows the variation in size and shape well.

But then I found this discussion over at DPreview which I believe you took part in Stan. Jostian who made the last post (when I looked) stated that Nikon repaired his D7000 stipulating that the mirror drive motor in early production units was the cause. Under certain conditions lube would push past the seals in the motor and spew lube. Again the oil spots shown by Canon and others are clear in the center and darker rings where these are blurry spots. And that’s why I state lubricant and not oil.

It would be nice to verify the statement by Jostian in that DPreview thread, for if that’s the case and the drive motor is pushing out lube, it will eventually fail out of warranty and be a costly repair I would think. If I can document it now, even though the camera is over one year, they might replace it for free. Assuming that is accurate and I have one of those early production cameras (I did purchase in 11/2010).

Pete


Edited to add:

Stan, I know it’s probably prohibited by Forum rules to post an illustration from one of the Tech manuals. But can you verify that there is such a mirror drive motor, where it would be located and if the armature shaft is in such a location that lubricant leaking from a seal could spin off the shaft toward the sensor. I know I said I had trouble wrapping my mind around the mirror mechanism itself, but I could see lubricant flipping off a rotating shaft if that’s the case. And bearing lubricant for a motor would be more opaque than precision oil used on a mechanism. Just curious.

Attachment#1 (jpg file)

Pete

Visit my Nikonians gallery.

This is a hot topic  It has been locked by a team member If not Lubricant…then what? [View all] , elec164 Silver Member , Wed 21-Dec-11 04:44 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
1
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
2
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
3
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
4
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
5
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
6
          Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
7
               Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
8
                    Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
10
                    Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
11
                         Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
15
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
12
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
9
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
16
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
19
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
32
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
13
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
14
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
17
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
18
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
20
          Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
21
          Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
22
               Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
24
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
23
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
25
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
26
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
29
Reply message OK... what now? RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
27
Reply message OK... what now? RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
28
Reply message OK... what now? RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
30
Reply message OK... what now? RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
37
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
31
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
33
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
34
          Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
35
               Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
36
                    Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
38
                    Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
39
                         Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
40
                    Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
41
                         Reply message Follow up to my previous post
42
                              Reply message RE: Follow up to my previous post
43
                              Reply message RE: Follow up to my previous post
44
                                   Reply message RE: Follow up to my previous post
45
                                        Reply message RE: Follow up to my previous post
46
Reply message RE: Repair update
47
Reply message RE: Repair update
48
     Reply message RE: Repair update
49
          Reply message RE: Repair update
50
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
51
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
52
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
53
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
54
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
56
          Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
57
               Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
59
                    Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
60
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
55
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
58
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
61
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
64
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
62
Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
63
     Reply message RE: If not Lubricant…then what?
65