Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

The 'FX' Effect.

briantilley

Paignton, UK
30235 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: The 'FX' Effect."

briantilley Gold Member Deep knowledge of bodies and lens; high level photography skills Donor Ribbon awarded for his support to the Fundraising Campaign 2014 Nikonian since 26th Jan 2003
Tue 08-Mar-11 05:54 PM | edited Tue 08-Mar-11 06:05 PM by briantilley

Sorry for the late reply - I've been away at the Focus on Imaging show for a coupl of days

Yes, I'm quite serious that there is no generic "FX Effect".

But... I think my posts on this subject may have been misinterpreted, either accidentally or deliberately. I will try once more to explain where I'm coming from.

I bought a D700 because it offered better noise performance than any other Nikon camera that I could afford. Its 1+ stop advantage over the D300 at high ISO's allows me to get more usable (i.e. saleable) shots of stage performances. The D700 is a remarkable camera, with an excellent balance of specification and performance that suits much of my work to a "T". Note that the D300 does a great job too, and at lower ISO settings I still don't see too much difference between them.

However, the fact that the D700 is an FX camera was (and is) is not relevant to my purchase decision. Because it's FX, I have had to alter which focal lengths I use to get the desired angles of view, and I still prefer the greater effective DoF of the D300 (for the same aperture and framing). If the "D400" (or whatever the next high-end DX camera turns out to be) can offer D700 levels of noise at ISO 6400 or so, it will be - FOR ME - an even better option. At that point, I could be shooting a "D400" for the longer shots and the D700 for wider full-stage views. With further improvements in technology, I might well switch fully back to DX.

I hope I've countered any impression that I don't rate the D700 very highly, but equally, I must emphasise one last time that the big improvements which the D700 offers over earlier DX cameras like the D200 and D2X are not all down to the format. An equally (arguably, more) important factor is that the D700 employs a newer generation of sensor and firmware. And that's what I mean by there being no "FX Effect". The D700 is great, but not (or not only) because it is FX

Brian
Welsh Nikonian

This is a hot, active topic! The 'FX' Effect. [View all] , Shy Talk Silver Member , Fri 04-Mar-11 11:37 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
1
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
2
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
3
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
84
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
101
Reply message RE: In reality
4
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
5
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
6
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
7
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
8
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
9
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
10
          Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
11
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
12
                    Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
13
                    Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
16
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
85
                              Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
87
                              Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
88
                              Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
90
                              Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
103
                    Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
14
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
15
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
17
                              Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
21
                                   Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
22
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
23
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
24
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
26
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
29
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
30
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
57
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
58
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
63
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
67
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
68
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
36
                                        Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
37
     Reply message RE: Correction
102
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
18
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
19
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
20
          Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
25
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
27
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
28
                    Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
31
                    Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
34
                    Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
35
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
38
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
43
                              Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
45
                                   Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
46
                                   Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
47
                                   Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
59
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
56
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
62
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
65
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
33
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
39
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
41
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
40
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
42
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
44
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
48
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
52
          Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
53
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
55
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
49
          Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
51
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
54
     Reply message RE: ?????
104
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
105
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
50
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
60
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
61
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
64
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
66
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
69
          Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
70
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
71
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
77
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
72
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
73
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
74
          Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
75
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
76
                    Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
78
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
79
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
80
                              Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
81
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
82
                              Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
83
                                   Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
86
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
89
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
91
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
92
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
93
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
94
          Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
95
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
96
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
98
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
97
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
99
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
100
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
106
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
107
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
108
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
109
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
110
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
111
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
112
Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
113
     Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
114
          Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
115
               Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
116
                    Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
117
                         Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
118
                              Reply message RE: The 'FX' Effect.
119