Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising
BJNicholls

Salt Lake City, US
10095 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash"

BJNicholls Gold Member Awarded for his contributions to the community and the Resources Charter Member
Sun 05-Jan-03 05:07 PM

Chris, Nikon couldn't figure out how to get reliable off-the-ccd metering with the original D1 camera. People trying to use TTL mode got very inconsistent results. Nikon came up with a workaround and introduced the SB-28 DX to provide a solution. In DX TTL metering, the flash exposure is metered during a preflash cycle (some super-rapid pulses before the shutter actually trips). The metering is done with light as it enters the camera rather than as it reflects off the CCD. This workaround works, but it is a step backward from "live" TTL where the the exposure can be modified as light changes during the actual exposure. And needless to say, this leaves Nikon DSLR users unable to use the existing Speelight system without taking several steps backward and using flash-controlled auto or manual modes.

The DX feature is NOT designed for all digital cameras, just Nikon's DSLR bodies. It is not needed for Coolpix cameras, nor is it needed for Kodak and Fuji cameras built from Nikon bodies. Both Fuji and Kodak provide off-the-chip metering and work with existing Nikon and Nikon compatible Speedlights. This issue was one of the most important reasons I went with a Fuji S2 instead of the D100. I didn't want to take a step backward in flash technology while having to buy new Speedlights to replace the two Nikon units I own.

From Nikon's standpoint, the DX thing is now a marketing plus. It also means that third party flashes with Nikon emulation won't provide TTL metering with Nikon's DSLR cameras. If you want 3D-TTL, with your D100 you have to buy a DX speedlight. Since the SB-28dx is being phased out, that gives you the SB-80dx and sb-50dx to choose from. Also note that wireless TTL (from the SU-4 and the SB-50DX) capability is compromised by the DX feature and Nikon warns against trying to use wireless TTL with its DSLR bodies.

Yes, you can work around the issues using flash auto and relying on your postview to check your settings. But I think it's time for Nikon to quit marketing a kludge as a feature and have Kodak or Fuji tell them how to meter off the chip.

BJ

Zenfolio gallery

A topic tagged as having a question D100 & Sunpak Flash [View all] , wpgf100 Awarded for his product reviews and other articles for the Resources Awarded for his shared and inspiring mastery of the art and science of photography , Thu 12-Dec-02 01:13 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
1
Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
2
     Reply message 3rd Party Flashes will only work in AA and Manual
3
          Reply message RE: 3rd Party Flashes will only work in AA and Manual
4
               Reply message RE: 3rd Party Flashes will only work in AA and Manual
5
                    Reply message RE: 3rd Party Flashes will only work in AA and Manual
6
Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
7
Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
8
     Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
14
Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
9
Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
10
Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
11
     Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
12
          Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
17
Reply message Nothing to say...
13
Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
15
     Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
16
          Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
19
          Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
20
Reply message RE: D100 & Sunpak Flash
18