Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH

elec164

US
2575 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH"

elec164 Silver Member Nikonian since 15th Jan 2009
Sat 11-Aug-12 01:48 PM

>I'm sorry to disagree with some others here, but flash guide
>numbers do not have units - it is a just a number.

I’ll be the first to admit; I’m not the sharpest tool in the shed and have had no formal training when it comes to photography. Being self-taught for the most part I realize that I may have numerous misconceptions (although I don’t think this is one of them, but I could be wrong!).

So with that said, perhaps I’m misunderstanding this phrase which is an excerpt from this article over at Nikon’s imaging web site.

“Quote”
“The flash guide number (GN) is a measure of the distance at which the flash can illuminate a subject.”
“Unquote”

I take that to mean what I defined in my first response and that is the GN listed in the specifications is the maximum distance a flash can reach and assumes an f-number of 1 and an ISO of 100 unless otherwise stipulated.

After all, to be a measure of distance would imply that it is associated with a particular metric otherwise it would be a meaningless number. For example if I tell you I have two flashes, one with a guide number of 40 and another with a guide number of 50, which is more powerful? You then might tell me the one with the GN of 50 at which time I tell you “oh yeah I forgot, the one with a GN of 40 is in meters and the one with 50 is in feet” you would then say “oh in that case the one with a GN of 40 is more powerful”.

So in that regard I believe my first response directly answered the OP, albeit perhaps not clear enough. Of course that is unless I am under a misconception in which case I must ask, “what am I missing here?”

Pete

Pete

Visit my Nikonians gallery.

A general, generic topic WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH [View all] , largebore Silver Member , Fri 10-Aug-12 12:53 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
1
Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
2
Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
3
     Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
4
          Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
5
               Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
6
                    Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
7
                    Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
9
                         Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
10
                         Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
11
                         Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
12
                              Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
15
                                   Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
16
                                   Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
17
                                   Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
18
                         Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
14
                    Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
13
Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
8
Reply message ALL CLEAR
19
Reply message RE: WHAT AM I MISSING ? GUIDE # FOR D200 FLASH
20