Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please

xtrememac

Andover, US
278 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please"

xtrememac Silver Member Nikonian since 05th Jan 2006
Sun 01-Apr-12 03:59 PM | edited Sun 01-Apr-12 05:23 PM by xtrememac

I had evaluated this camera on paper well before having one for a long term evaluation. If you search prior postings you will find my comments on the things I did and did not like on paper. A number of the issues I expressed here I had expressed concern with on paper.

My hope was that the D4 would provide a significantly superior experience in image quality, handling, focus speed or other aspect that could only be experienced by actual evaluation that would mitigate or at least offset the downside of the goofy card setup, for instance. Granted given my dislike for the impact such a storage system the pros would have to be quite a bit better than the D3s I so dearly love. After a thorough evaluation of the product itself, I wrote the piece you refer to. Sadly, the D4 by my and many other reviewers comments does not surpass the D3s in a significant way in image quality or handling, and does not deliver the same portrait look that I love in the D3s. These evaluations could not be done on paper.

Again, as I said I was evaluating the unit for my use, not general use. The D4 may be the perfect choice for some, just not me. For those who own a D3s, and do not care about video, wait for the next model. If you do not own a pro body, you have a choice...

However, no matter who uses it, the D4 card setup using 2 unmatched cards (including one the 2 largest suppliers of professional camera memory (Sandisk and Lexar) have no current plans to manufacture) remains goofy and unprofessional IMO.

It is my sincere hope that nobody gets stuck with a $6k camera with an orphaned card slot. That decision is a lot different for the enthusiast with a couple of cards and the pro with literally thousands tied up in the latest CF cards, but again, YMMV.

Sincerely,

K. J. Doyle

Visit my Nikonians gallery.

Visit my Nikonians gallery.

This is a hot, active topic! D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please [View all] , houstonjim1 Silver Member , Thu 22-Mar-12 09:54 AM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
1
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
2
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
3
          Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
8
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
4
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
6
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
53
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
5
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
7
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
9
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
10
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
11
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
12
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
13
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
14
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
15
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
16
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
17
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
18
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
19
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
20
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
21
          Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
22
               Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
46
               Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
47
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
54
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
23
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
24
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
25
          Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
26
          Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
28
          Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
29
          Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
27
               Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
30
               Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
31
                    Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
32
                    Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
34
                    Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
36
               Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
33
               Reply message I have overrun the D4 buffer with XQD and Lexar 1000X
52
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
40
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
35
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
56
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
57
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - this requires a sense of humour ...
37
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - this requires a sense of humour ...
39
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - this requires a sense of humour ...
41
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - this requires a sense of humour ...
43
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - this requires a sense of humour ...
44
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - this requires a sense of humour ...
45
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - this requires a sense of humour ...
48
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
38
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
42
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
49
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
50
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
51
Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
55
     Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
58
          Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
59
               Reply message RE: D4 vs. D3s - opinions from new D4 owners please
60