Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8

LMMiller9

Potomac, US
1168 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8"

LMMiller9 Silver Member Nikonian since 18th Dec 2005
Tue 29-Jan-13 02:19 AM

Very simply, I did the comparison tests because I wanted to see how the images of the two lenses compared. My question, to myself, was "Do I keep the heavier and more expensive 2.8 now that I have purchased the 4.0?"

I was amazed, even in low light, how well the 4.0 compared to the 2.8. However, as was pointed out to me during the course of this discussion, it won't do so well with a moving subject, which I didn't test.

The test help me understand how good the new 4.0/VRIII is. On a day with good light, going to the beach with a dog, for example (see the link I posted) I don't believe there will be any advantage to the heavier 2.8.

The only purpose was to share the comparison and let people draw their own conclusions.

Larry Miller, Potomac, MD
DF/D810
http://lmmillerphotography.smugmug.com/

Visit my Nikonians gallery.

This is a hot, active topic! Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8 [View all] , LMMiller9 Silver Member , Tue 01-Jan-13 04:06 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
1
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
2
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
96
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
3
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
4
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
5
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
6
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
7
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
8
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
9
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
60
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
10
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
11
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
12
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
13
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
14
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
15
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
17
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
43
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
18
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
63
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
78
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
80
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
22
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
44
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
48
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
67
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
81
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
62
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
70
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
98
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
16
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
19
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
20
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
21
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
23
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
24
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
25
                                   Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
26
                                   Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
49
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
68
                                   Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
71
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
27
                                   Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
28
                                        Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
29
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
30
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
31
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
32
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
33
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
34
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
35
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
36
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
37
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
38
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
39
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
59
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
40
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
41
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
42
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
45
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
46
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
58
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
47
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
50
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
51
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
57
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
99
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
52
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
53
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
54
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
55
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
56
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
66
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
69
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
72
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
73
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
74
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
75
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
76
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
79
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
82
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
83
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
84
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
85
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
86
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
87
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
88
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
89
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
90
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
91
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
92
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
93
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
94
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
95
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
97
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
100
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
101
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
102