Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8

LMMiller9

Potomac, US
1168 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8"

LMMiller9 Silver Member Nikonian since 18th Dec 2005
Tue 01-Jan-13 05:06 PM | edited Tue 01-Jan-13 05:21 PM by LMMiller9

I two days ago I received the new 70-200/f4. I already had the 70-200/f2.8VRII. So, the natural question is, can this new lens that weighs about half and costs about half match the image quality of the more expensive lens in different light and shooting conditions?

Caveat: I am not a pro or a professional tester. I did my best to set up different conditions for comparison. I'll let you be the judge of the relative image quality. All taken with the D800.

I always have trouble uploading here so I have put them in my Smugmug gallery: http://lmmillerphotography.smugmug.com/Photography/Lens-Tests. Click on the "Info" button for each photo so you can see the #. At the bottom of each photo there is a caption indicating which lens it is.

Test 1: Very poor light. Manual setting of ISO800, f/4, 1/60sec, handheld with VR on. I also included the 85mm/f1.4 for comparison. In all cases the light is inadequate, but interesting to see the relative performance. Which do you think is better?

#3166 is the f4.0
#3167 is the 85mm/f1.4
#3168 is the f2.8

Test 2: Setting programmed auto; all at 85mm; auto ISO; again handheld in the same actual light as the above sequence.

#3169 is the f2.8
#3170 is the f4.0
#3171 is the 85mm.

Test 3: On a tripod and using flash. Again programmed auto setting.

#3159 is the f2.8
#3160 is the f4.0

Test 4: Outdoors in pretty good light. This open house sign is about 150 yards away. This is an extreme crop and at 100%. Setting is on program auto. ISO set at 400. These are taken on a tripod.

#3136 is the f2.8
#3139 is the f4.0

Test 5: Also outdoors in relatively good light but aimed at a store front that is very much in the shadows. This is cropped. The distance is about 300 yards, taken on a tripod. Again programmed auto.

#3132 is the f2.8
#3140 is the f4.0

I'll let you be the judge. Personally, I am amazed.

Larry Miller, Potomac, MD
DF/D810
http://lmmillerphotography.smugmug.com/

Visit my Nikonians gallery.

This is a hot, active topic! Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8 [View all] , LMMiller9 Silver Member , Tue 01-Jan-13 04:06 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
1
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
2
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
96
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
3
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
4
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
5
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
6
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
7
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
8
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
9
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
60
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
10
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
11
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
12
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
13
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
14
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
15
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
17
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
43
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
18
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
63
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
78
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
80
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
22
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
44
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
48
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
67
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
81
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
62
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
70
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
98
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
16
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
19
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
20
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
21
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
23
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
24
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
25
                                   Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
26
                                   Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
49
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
68
                                   Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
71
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
27
                                   Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
28
                                        Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
29
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
30
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
31
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
32
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
33
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
34
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
35
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
36
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
37
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
38
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
39
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
59
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
40
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
41
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
42
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
45
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
46
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
58
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
47
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
50
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
51
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
57
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
99
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
52
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
53
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
54
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
55
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
56
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
66
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
69
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
72
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
73
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
74
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
75
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
76
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
79
     Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
82
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
83
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
84
          Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
85
               Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
86
                    Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
87
                         Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
88
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
89
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
90
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
91
                              Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
92
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
93
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
94
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
95
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
97
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
100
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
101
Reply message RE: Comparison: 70-200 f4 vs f2.8
102