Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED

blw

Richmond, US
28713 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to send message via AOL IM

"RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED"

blw Moderator Awarded for his high level of expertise in various areas Nikonian since 18th Jun 2004
Sat 29-Dec-12 04:44 PM

Sorry, I didn't provide a complete picture. I also have a 28-105/f3.5-4.5 AFD in inventory already; also I have a fairly complete set of Micro-Nikkors: 60 AFS, 105 AFD, 200 AFD. And I have fast telephoto primes: 135/f2 and 180/f2.8. So really all I need is a high quality VR zoom and a fast wide angle.

As far as the price of the 24-120/f4 vs its quality, the quality is good enough for my purposes. I know plenty of pros or serious amateurs that use the 24-120 (Jon for example!), and besides I'm of the opinion that sharpness is overrated anyway. There are very few situations where the 24-120/f4 isn't good enough AND the primes are not flexible enough, and very, very few of even that small set is actually addressed by the 24-70/f2.8. There are also few situations in which an f/4 with VR is not good enough low light, and in those cases I'm not willing to spend the extra $$$ and weight for the f/1.4 versions of the 24 and 85.

Would I go for the 24-85VR if I didn't already have a 28-105? Quite possibly, particularly at this moment when the 24-85 is about to suffer from a supply glut.

_____
Brian... a bicoastal Nikonian and Team Member

My gallery is online. Comments and critique welcomed any time!

This is a hot, active topic! Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED [View all] , jef_dk4 , Sat 29-Dec-12 04:14 AM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
1
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
2
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
3
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
4
     Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
7
     Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
26
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
5
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
6
     Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
8
     Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
9
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
10
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
11
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
12
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
13
     Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
15
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
14
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
16
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
17
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
20
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
18
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
19
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
21
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
22
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
23
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
24
     Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
25
          Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
27
               Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
28
               Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
29
               Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
30
               Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
33
               Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
31
                    Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
32
                         Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
50
                              Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
51
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
34
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
35
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
36
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
37
     Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
38
          Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
39
               Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
40
               Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
41
               Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
44
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
42
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
43
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
45
     Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
46
          Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
47
          Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
48
          Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
49
          Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
52
               Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
53
                    Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
54
                    Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
56
                    Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
57
                    Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
58
                    Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
65
                    Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
59
                         Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
60
                              Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
61
                                   Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
62
                                        Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
63
                                             Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
64
Reply message RE: Sadly giving up on the wonderful 24-70 AFS ED
55