Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

New 24-85 VR on D800

jadiniz

Estoril, PT
350 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: New 24-85 VR on D800"

jadiniz Registered since 25th Dec 2010
Wed 19-Dec-12 11:10 AM

I too am contemplating getting this lens for my D600.

When I was in DX-land, my lens kit was the general 16-85mm, the tele 70-300mm, and a prime 35mm. Jumping to FX, I kept the tele, sold the general zoom and replaced my beloved prime with the equivalent 50mm f1.8G.

And now I have two choices to go about, considering funds are very limited: I could either go the prime way, and get the 28mm f1.8G and the 85mm f1.8G (with the 50 those would make a nice trio), or simply get the 24-85 and sort of repicate what I had with DX.

The reports I'm getting about the 28mm are mixed: not too wide, some field curvature issues (which might make wide aperture use finicky), and it's more expensive than the 24-85. The 85mm gets stellar reviews, but I find it is a very specialized lens, and for portraiture and general tele the 70-300 VR does fine (although I'd love to get a 70-200 f4 VR, too, but it's still a lot of money).

I could also try to get an older general zoom, like the 28-105 AF-D, 24-85 AF-D or 24-120 AF-D, but none of those has VR, and I find that handy. Mixed reviews also don't bring much peace of mind about some of those lenses.

I know the point of going FX is kinda lost here, and this 24-85 might not make the D600 justice, but, as I said, times are tight. My main shooting, without a doubt, is with the nifty fifty, but the tele comes in very handy for portraiture and the eventual daylight kids sports and activities. Likewise, a general zoom may not provide the best IQ or capabilities, but it's priceless for those family times and travelling (I'm a big fan of lightweight lenses for this). Strictly amateur use for me, so heavyweight f2.8 zooms are out of the question due to size, weight and price.

I probably should have gotten the D600 with the kit lens, but money comes slow, and I choose to get the camera first, lens latter.

Having the 50 and the 70-300, what you YOU rather add: the 28mm f1.8G or the 24-85mm VR? Forgot to add, for ultra-wide(ish) I also have a borrowed 20mm f2.8D, so that specialty is covered (although not in spades, I must say).

http://egozarolho.blogspot.com
1. Good content, good aesthetics and good tecnique. On that order.
2. Light is more important than glass and pixels.
3. In the digital photography process, software is as important as gear.

This is a hot, active topic! New 24-85 VR on D800 [View all] , wmcy Gold Member , Thu 13-Dec-12 03:59 AM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
1
Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
2
Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
3
Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
4
Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
6
     Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
7
          Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
8
          Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
20
               Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
21
Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
5
Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
9
Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
10
Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
11
     Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
12
          Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
13
               Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
14
                    Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
15
                    Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
16
                    Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
17
                    Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
18
                         Reply message RE: New 24-85 VR on D800
19