Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?

mklass

Tacoma, US
7437 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?"

mklass Platinum Member As a semi-professional involved in all manner of photographic genres including portraiture, sports, commercial, and events coverage, Mick is always ready to help Nikonians by sharing his deep knowledge of photography and printing. Donor Ribbon awarded for his generous support to the Fundraising Campaign 2014 Nikonian since 08th Dec 2006
Thu 25-Oct-12 04:22 PM

If you don't have a lens in this focal length range, and the price of the f/2.8 is a roadblock, this lens is a good idea.

Being smaller and lighter than the f/2.8 it may be easier to hold steady and get better performance from the VR. If VRIII has some new tricks then maybe 4 stops is possible. (I tend to go with the thought that Nikon seems to overstate VR effectiveness by 1 stop.)

Yes, you don't get the same DOF at f/4 as you do at f/2.8, VR or no VR. Usefulness depends on whether you want the larger aperture to get enough light to capture a sharp image or if you are going for DOF. If this lens at f/4 with VRIII is truly effective, then you can theoretically shoot the same scene as with the f/2.8 with VRII, but the DOF will be different.

I've already got the f/2.8 vII so have no interest in the f/4 lens. I have other lenses that are on my priority list. However, if I did not have a 70-200, this seems like it would be worth considering.

Of course, all of this is BS until people get their hands on the thing and and report how well it works. Good god, it may have "flecks" inside the barrel!


Mick
http://www.mickklassphoto.com
or
Visit my nikonians gallery

This is a hot, active topic! 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot? [View all] , Noel Holland Platinum Member Winner in the Nikonians 10th Anniversary Photo Contest , Wed 24-Oct-12 01:29 PM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
1
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
2
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
4
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
3
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
26
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
5
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
34
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
6
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
7
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
8
     Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
9
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
10
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
11
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
12
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
14
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
31
     Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
32
          Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
33
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
16
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
13
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
15
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
17
     Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
18
     Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
19
     Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
20
          Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
21
               Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
22
               Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
23
               Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
24
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
25
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
28
     Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
30
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
27
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
29
Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
35
     Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
36
     Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
37
          Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
38
               Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
39
     Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
40
          Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
41
               Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
42
               Reply message RE: 5 Stops VR? Has Nikon Marketing lost the plot?
43