Even though we ARE Nikon lovers,we are NOT affiliated with Nikon Corp. in any way.

English German French

Sign up Login
Home Forums Articles Galleries Recent Photos Contest Help Search News Workshops Shop Upgrade Membership Recommended
members
All members Wiki Contests Vouchers Apps Newsletter THE NIKONIAN™ Magazines Podcasts Fundraising

Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...

johngie

Mold, UK
300 posts

Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author

"RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)..."

johngie Registered since 07th Jul 2007
Mon 20-Jul-09 07:12 PM

That's correct. I guess the only reason it's not called a F2.8-5.6 is that, by convention, the F number is defined as the geometrical ratio of the focal length (at infinity) divided by the effective diameter of the lens.

Years ago there was a move to re-define the light transmission value of a lens by its T (transmission) number, that would account for variations not only in its extension but also the actual attenuation of light passing through the glass. Unfortunately (I feel) it didn't catch on except amongst the optical technologists.

You are not the only one to be "caught out" by this. Only this month a respected UK magazine reviewed the Micro-Nikkor and actually implied that this lens "behaved oddly" because the camera reported (correctly) this effective change in F-number as the lens was extended. Far from odd, this is just what *should* happen and one could argue that all the others are "wrong". I've emailed the magazine concerned to suggest that its reviewer needs to revise his knowledge of simple optics before making such statements!

John Gruffydd
Mold, Wales, UK
D300, D200, OM1, OM2n, Bronica ETRSi, Lumix LX5

Pinned topic Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)... [View all] , SzennyBoy Awarded for his shared hands-on experience in macro photography within the community forums and the Resources , Sun 29-Dec-02 10:02 AM
Subject
ID
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
1
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
2
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
21
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
44
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
34
     Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
35
          Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
36
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
3
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
4
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
5
     Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
6
          Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
7
               Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
8
                    Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
9
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
60
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
10
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
11
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
12
Reply message RE: Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)/ further imp
13
Reply message RE: Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)/ further imp
14
     Reply message RE: Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)/ further imp
15
          Reply message RE: Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)/ further imp
16
               Reply message RE: Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)/ further imp
17
               Reply message RE: Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)/ further imp
18
               Reply message RE: Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)/ further imp
64
               Reply message RE: Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)/ further imp
19
                    Reply message RE: Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)/ further imp
20
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
22
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
23
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
24
     Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
25
          Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
26
          Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
42
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
27
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
28
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
29
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
30
     Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)
31
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
32
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
33
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
37
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
38
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
39
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
40
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
41
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
68
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
43
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
45
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
46
     Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
47
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
48
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
49
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
54
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
55
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
56
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
57
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
58
     Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
59
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
65
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
66
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
67
Reply message RE: Understanding Macro Lens Apertures (Micro-Nikkors)...
69