Nikonians Review

home > resources > software > 20. Adobe Lightroom - Editing an Adobe Lightroom file in Photoshop CS2

Adobe Digital Photography Workflow - 20
by George Mann

username (George Mann)
Nikonian in Thailand

tell a friend about this article

  Introduction
» Editing an Adobe Lightroom file in Photoshop CS2

20. Adobe Lightroom - Editing an Adobe Lightroom file in Photoshop CS2

Article 20 of 100

 

Adobe Lightroom Export screen
Adobe Lightroom Export screen

-- ADVERTISEMENT --


As mentioned in the previous article on Exporting files from Adobe Lightroom, if you need to save your exported files in anything other than JPEG, TIFF or DNG, or to exercise more than a minimum amount of control over those files, you have no other choice but to use the Edit in Adobe Photoshop CS 2 or Edit in ....... (another program of your choice) command in the Photo menu.

As you can see from the dialog box above there is one of three choices that has to be made on how you want to handle the file you are planning to edit externally, but if you are editing a RAW or DNG file the first two choices are grayed out.

When you are working with a RAW image file and choose Edit a Copy with Lightroom Adjustments, Lightroom will make a copy of the image in TIFF file format and place it into the Lightroom Library next to the original image with the same file name plus (-Edit.TIFF), a second image would be labeled (-Edit-1.TIFF).

After you have made your edits to that file in an external editor, you can Save that file and it will show up in Adobe Lightroom with the changes you have made. You can not however do a file Save As and change the file format. If you started with a RAW file your edited file will be the TIFF file mentioned above. If you need a JPEG file you can of course do a file Save As to a new location and Import that file into the Adobe Lightroom Library as a new file.

The Edit Original command is for editing JPEG or TIFF files that are in your Adobe Lightroom Library, you should be careful to have another copy of the original safely stored (inside or outside of Adobe Lightroom) with this command because it will change the image that is in the Adobe Lightroom Library and you will not be able to undo the changes.

The Edit a Copy command is the safe way to deal with JPEG and TIFF files in your Adobe Lightroom Library when you want to edit them in Adobe Photoshop CS or another external image editor. A copy will first be made in Adobe Lightroom before the image is moved to the image editor for whatever changes you have planned. The changes will then only be applied to the copy and not the original.

As you can see from the image above, your screen can become pretty crowded with both Adobe Lightroom and Adobe Photoshop CS2 on the desktop at the same time but the process is pretty straight forward.

In the last article I had suggested that most of the file saving functions of Adobe Photoshop CS should be incorporated into Adobe Lightroom. I have had a slight change of heart since then, I still think the Export file function of Adobe Lightroom could be improved but I also realize that there is no way that it could incorporate all the save functions of Adobe Photoshop CS. Crowded desktop or not, Adobe Photoshop CS and Adobe Lightroom are both here to stay.


P.S.: Please do not get upset if your personal experience and views are different from my own. These opinions are mine exclusively and do not reflect the views or policies of any of the manufacturers mentioned in this article...... George Mann

  More ...»
see also

Digital post processing & workflow forum
Proud to be a Nikonian
Nikonians Bookshelf 14 - Digital Photography Books
"You might be a Nikonian if ..." T-Shirt


About - Contact - Advertise - News - RSS - Newsletters - Membership - Awards - Testimonials - Terms - Privacy - Help

Copyright Nikonians 2000, 2008
All Rights Reserved


Nikonians is a registered trademark of Nikonians.org
Nikon, Nikonos and Nikkor are registered trademarks of Nikon Corporation.

The nikonia, nikonian and nikonians domains are not associated with Nikon Corporation
nor with any of its subsidiaries or affiliates in any way.

This community is best visited using a JavaScript enabled generation 4 browser or later
with a monitor resolution of 800 x 600 or higher.