Hi All, I have Lightroom 4 (LR4) and Photoshop Elements 10 (PSE10). The version of the collection that works in both LR4 and PSE10 costs $500 while the version that works only in LR4 costs $300.
If I purchase the version that works in LR4 but not in PSE10 will this be usable for me. They way I would use it would be to apply the NIK filters/plugins in LR4 and then do additional editing in PSE10. is this going to be a viable workflow. -- I am not a professional - just a serious amateur.
Thu 31-Jan-13 05:18 AM | edited Thu 31-Jan-13 05:19 AM by mklass
The LR version actually allows you to use each plug-in as a standalone program. You can either start it from LR, or you can drag and drop an image file onto an icon on your desktop for the plug-in. (The plug-ins, except for HDR Efex, do not have a file|open menu.)
One last thing that is confusing me. I watched the NIK videos that demonstrate the workflow that shows how you use each product sequentially. It shows that when you do some steps that new layers are created. Since Lightroom doesn't have layers I'm not sure what is going on. hope I am explaining my question well.
It's probably showing the plug-ins being used in Photoshop. There is a great deal more flexibility if you use plug-ins in Elements via layers (I think that works - I don't own Elements) and even more in the full Photoshop where you can update and edit the plug-ins' parameters via the smart filter function.
I'm sure your right. I was trying to avoid buying the Full Version because it's $200 more expensive. My question is really --is it a useful tool if it is launched from Lightroom where layers are not available.
Different people have different preferences. Even though I have the LR plug-ins in addition to the Photoshop ones and use both LR and Photoshop, I never use the LR plug-ins. For me, there is a lot of value in isolating the changes to a layer. I use more than one filter fairly often, and layers are one way to isolate those changes. In addition, you can vary the opacity of a layer to vary the strength of a filter at a later date.
I actually go a step further and have most everything in my workflow non-destructive because I sometimes change my mind about how an image should look and don't want to recreate everything from scratch. It can be easy to either undershoot or overshoot an edit, and it's no fun creating a bunch of edits and control points from scratch again. Unfortunately, you can't do all of that with Elements, but you can handle portions of it.
I found an excellent tutorial on you tube http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LeHNLIr1zBc (produced by NIK) which explains how to use NIK software in Lightroom. They show how to do selective edits without needing Photoshop. It seems very powerful. They also give a promocode which they say provides a 15% discount. Based on this I think I will buy the Lightroom only version.
Here's another thought: I use the entire NIK suite for Lightroom, not wanting the complete suite for the same financial reason. So, I can't go back and tweak the filters, right? Well, not entirely. Alllow me to explain. I mostly use CEP4. I really love it to death. I've made some custom recipes and that's when I got the idea: imagine going from LR to CEP4 and applying an intricate yet elaborate set of carefully fine-tuned filters. Now, if I want to be able to come back and tweak the options some way, I save the current setting to a recipe I call ''Temp'', and next time around I just start from the orig. picture, apply the Temp recipe and continue from there. A small way to save 200 bucks. I'm sure: not the same thing as smart filters, but it gets close.
I now have the Nik plu-in that work with LR & Photoshop. So now, like Rick I apply Nik as layer in PS.
Up until 6 months ago, I have Nik edition that works with LR only. In that work flow: for each Nik filter (CEP, Vivaza, SilverEfex etc.) it go from LR-to-Nik, save as Tiff back to LR, and the send that tiff to Nik again for the next filter. So yes I end up with several tiff files if i apply more than 1 Nik filter, plus Photoshop/Element sometime. That was comber some, I like my new workflow better.
Anyone know if there is an upgrade available from the Lightroom/Aperture collection ($299) to the Photoshop collection ($499) if one decides they need the Photoshop functionality later? The NIK website does not seem to indicate.
There is no 'upgrade packege' from Lightroom/Aperature colllection to PS version per say, but you just switch over to the Photoshop complete collection version. When I did that in Oct 2012, it cost US$200 + tax.