jdroach Milwaukee, US Nikonian since 21st Mar 2009
Fri 02-Nov-12 04:26 PM
"Sunset at White Sands -- a Study"
I offer 5 images. The first two images are experiments in more painterly image making using HDR Photomatix. The darker image is a combination of 11 exposures (that was just over the top for me and an obvious experiment) with the extensive range of multiple stops in each direction. The second and lighter image is a created from 5 images. Rarely do I venture into the less then natural look when doing HDR and most often use only three exposure with max of 2 EV differential, but I thought, why not. Lets see where it goes. The third image offered is a single more realistic rendering of the scene with a slightly different perspective (zoomed in) of the first image. The fourth image is a single exposure with it more or less matching the second image without using HDR. The fifth image, because I like it is a single exposure added for good measure. I think the comparisons in painterly HDR vs. traditional image making is an interesting study. I used a D700, 28-300mm lens, using manual exposure and white balance in the experiments with 1600 ISO. Tripod mounted on Gitzo Tripod with a Markin Q20 Ball Head. All other processing was done in Lightroom 4.2. I welcome any comments and discussion about these experiments.
Looking West (11 exposures with Photomatix and LR4) --
Looking East (5 exposures with Photomatix and LR4) --
Looking West (single exposure with LR4 only) --
Looking East (single exposure with LR4 only) --
Looking Northwest (single exposure with LR4 only) --
jdroach, a Milwaukee area and sometimes Chicago area Nikonian.
rb4good Rocky Hill, US Nikonian since 22nd May 2006
Fri 02-Nov-12 09:10 PM
#1. "RE: Sunset at White Sands -- a Study" In response to Reply # 0
Nice experiment,John. I'll give my take and I'm sure others will have different opinions than mine.
I like both "looking west" images. The 1st I would crop out half the sky and make it panoramic.The 2nd (1 frame)I like as is and is my favorite of them.
I don't really care for the "looking east" pics but can vision the 1st(5 images) printed big and hanging on someones wall. The second just does not appeal to me at all as there is nothing in the sky and the ground is kind of bland looking to my eye.
The last image I also like but I may have lightened the sand a tad more,love the sky. Thanks for posting this.