
Toronto, CA
|
I think I disagree with you because I have the impression that both reviews did touch on all of the same things/points/features more or less. It's just that the reviews were balanced in somewhat different ways. I think that "balance" is an elusive goal, and that in the course of questing for completely even balance as a reviewer the end result will more often be mediocrity rather than balance. I don't know how (or if) you are personally swayed by a single review. The thing is, it is only after reading several reviews of the same product that we are able to derive some sort of broadly detailed opinion about whether or not the product might suit out needs or interests. Expecting anything else may be, I think, somewhat unrealistic.
I think that most photography product reviews are, in fact, balanced from the perspective of the reviewer. That some sense of balance doesn't feel present after you've personally taken in a few of the reviews is only an indication that you, personally also, have definite opinions about what priorities should be emphasized or balanced in camera product reviews. There is not a right balance - reviewers have biases, they're fallible, and they have their own personal photography preferences (street, landscape, portraiture, wildlife, art, architecture, etc., etc., etc.).
If reviewers tried to write them simultaneously according to both your definition of what constitutes balance and my definition, it would most often produce a mighty confusing or cross-purposed review. I think you're a perfectly good photographer, but I'm just not interested in shooting the same things that interest you - not at all. For that reason, I seek out reviewers over the years who use equipment for the same purposes as I do. I get the most accurate opinions, for my needs, in doing so. I recommend that all Nikonians do the same - seek out product reviewers who are interested in their sort of photography.
I think that as long as a particular reviewer isn't overly brand-biased (e.g., hammering a Nikon or Sony product because he's a Canon nut) that balance in reviews is already present and that most reviewers, review teams and publications produce their own 'take' on what constitutes that balance.
My Nikonians Gallery
Howard Carson, Managing Editor Kickstartnews Inc. - http://www.kickstartnews.com
|