Go to a  "printer friendly" view of this message which allow an easy print Printer-friendly copy Go to the page which allows you to send this topic link and a message to a friend Email this topic to a friend
Forums Lobby GET TO KNOW YOUR CAMERA & MASTER IT Nikon D7100, D7000 (Public) topic #21406
View in linear mode

Subject: "RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
This message is locked.
elec164 Silver Member Nikonian since 15th Jan 2009Mon 05-Nov-12 02:59 PM
1988 posts Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin    Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profile
#96. "RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem"
In response to In response to 77


US
          

>I was thinking the same.
>Definitely not sharp.


I had a thought on this when David made his comment on sharpness, but let it pass without posting.

But now that you have brought it up again, I felt my thoughts might bring an alternate idea to the discussion.

The original posting was about accuracy of autofocus not of sharpness. And to me Jacques’ woodpecker image is a good example of an image with acceptable focus, but low in acutance. And a quick trip into PS with a modicum of Smart Sharpening cleans it up nicely. We often think that sharpness is mutually inclusive with focus, but they aren’t.

There are a number of factors that can affect acuity, focus being one of them. When I look at Jacques’ example, again it appears that the plane of focus is contained within the subject. So we then must ask what caused the low acuity. One thing already mentioned in this thread is the AA filter. Another is interpolation. Jacques mentioned it’s about a 60% crop, but I not sure if he meant that 60% was cropped away leaving 40%, or 40% was cropped away leaving 60%. Then again did he mean that he cropped out a section that would equate to 60%view in an editor such as PS much like the term “100% crop” is used? In either case, it would seem that he would have needed to down-sample the image to meet posting requirements. So perhaps the lower acuity (or sharpness if you will) is due to improper file handling (lack of resharpening after resampling) and not poor AF accuracy.

Also, you often see complaints about the D7000 with people comparing the results with their other cameras. Quite often there a mix of DX and FF 12 MP bodies. An inherent danger when comparing different resolution bodies is a failure to remain cognizant of what you’re looking at with 100% view. Not knowing what Jackques meant by his example, I’ll use an example that I used about a year ago when someone asked what I thought about my AF accuracy after the repair compared to prior to repair (it was repaired for lubricant spray issue not AF, but the teardown necessitated a recalibration of the AF).

For reference this is the full DX frame capture.

Hand held at 300mm with VR on, f/5.6, 1/200th and ISO160.





And this is a 100% crop of the bird.



Now those two images were processed from the NEF.

It appears to me that the AF was fairly accurate, and even the 100% crop looks rather good.

Now, this is a 100% crop of the NEF without processing (no levels or curves adjustments and no sharpening other than capture sharpening in LR3).




The focus was the same, the difference is the acutance. The unprocessed shot does not restore the loss of acutance from the AA filter. Also, at 100% view on the average monitor, you are seeing the effects of diffraction as well. And perhaps that is where a number of people go astray, especially when comparing their new higher resolution bodies to their older lower resolution bodies.

For example my monitor displays about 93 PPI. A D7000 full resolution image displayed at 100% would be about a 57x enlargement. A D90 image would be about 49x and a D700 would be about 32x enlargement. In my example the diffraction spot size at f/5.6 is about 7 microns. My viewing distance is about 30 inches or about 1.6x the viewing distance of an 8x10 in which the tolerable CoC is often calculated. With the D7000 at 57x enlargement the diffraction spot size in my example would become about .4mm; so it would appear relatively soft. With the D90 at 49x enlargement, the diffraction spot size becomes around .34mm and at the viewing distance would be at the edge of appearing relatively sharp. With the D700 and its 32x enlargement, the spot size becomes around .224mm and is well within the acceptably sharp range for the CoC.

So when we analyze real world images, a lack of sharpness doesn’t necessarily mean a lack of focus accuracy. But a lack of accurate focus will cause a lack of sharpness.

Pete


Pete

Visit my Nikonians gallery.

Attachment #1, (jpg file)

  

Alert Printer-friendly copy

This is a hot topic – It has been locked by a team memberNikon D7000 Focus Problem [View all] , photoman2112 , Mon 08-Oct-12 04:56 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
RSchussel Silver Member
08th Oct 2012
1
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
08th Oct 2012
2
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Davidpeter1 Silver Member
19th Oct 2012
33
          Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
AlexRitchie
02nd Nov 2012
74
               Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
avv1865
04th Nov 2012
87
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
km6xz Moderator
08th Oct 2012
3
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
08th Oct 2012
4
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
dm1dave Administrator
08th Oct 2012
5
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
RSchussel Silver Member
09th Oct 2012
6
          Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
luckyphoto Silver Member
09th Oct 2012
7
               Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
09th Oct 2012
8
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
briantilley Moderator
09th Oct 2012
9
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
mudman2 Silver Member
09th Oct 2012
10
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
grillij Silver Member
13th Oct 2012
14
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
dm1dave Administrator
09th Oct 2012
11
                         Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
11th Oct 2012
12
                              Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
km6xz Moderator
13th Oct 2012
13
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
kippford Silver Member
13th Oct 2012
15
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
13th Oct 2012
16
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
grillij Silver Member
13th Oct 2012
17
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
NDGraham Silver Member
14th Oct 2012
18
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
grillij Silver Member
14th Oct 2012
19
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
14th Oct 2012
20
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
grillij Silver Member
14th Oct 2012
21
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
14th Oct 2012
22
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
mudman2 Silver Member
14th Oct 2012
23
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
14th Oct 2012
24
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Vsteelrider
14th Oct 2012
25
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
14th Oct 2012
26
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Vsteelrider
14th Oct 2012
27
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
14th Oct 2012
28
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Davidpeter1 Silver Member
19th Oct 2012
31
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
grillij Silver Member
19th Oct 2012
32
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Davidpeter1 Silver Member
19th Oct 2012
34
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
grillij Silver Member
19th Oct 2012
35
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Davidpeter1 Silver Member
22nd Oct 2012
38
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
grillij Silver Member
22nd Oct 2012
39
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
briantilley Moderator
20th Oct 2012
36
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
AlexRitchie
02nd Nov 2012
77
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
grillij Silver Member
03rd Nov 2012
82
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
cwils02 Gold Member
03rd Nov 2012
84
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
elec164 Silver Member
05th Nov 2012
96
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
J_Harris Silver Member
05th Nov 2012
97
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
grillij Silver Member
05th Nov 2012
98
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
J_Harris Silver Member
05th Nov 2012
99
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
RLDubbya Silver Member
05th Nov 2012
101
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
RLDubbya Silver Member
15th Oct 2012
29
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
mudman2 Silver Member
15th Oct 2012
30
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
NDGraham Silver Member
22nd Oct 2012
37
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
28th Oct 2012
40
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
briantilley Moderator
28th Oct 2012
41
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
RLDubbya Silver Member
29th Oct 2012
42
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
km6xz Moderator
29th Oct 2012
43
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
30th Oct 2012
44
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
30th Oct 2012
45
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
30th Oct 2012
46
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
elec164 Silver Member
30th Oct 2012
48
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
30th Oct 2012
47
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
cwils02 Gold Member
04th Nov 2012
89
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
05th Nov 2012
91
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
cwils02 Gold Member
05th Nov 2012
92
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
benmlee
05th Nov 2012
90
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
briantilley Moderator
05th Nov 2012
93
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
cwils02 Gold Member
05th Nov 2012
94
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
RLDubbya Silver Member
05th Nov 2012
100
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
cwils02 Gold Member
06th Nov 2012
103
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
benmlee
05th Nov 2012
102
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
30th Oct 2012
49
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
kingsgraphic
30th Oct 2012
50
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
km6xz Moderator
31st Oct 2012
53
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
kingsgraphic
31st Oct 2012
54
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
briantilley Moderator
31st Oct 2012
55
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
01st Nov 2012
58
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
briantilley Moderator
01st Nov 2012
59
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
01st Nov 2012
61
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
02nd Nov 2012
69
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
J_Harris Silver Member
01st Nov 2012
60
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
01st Nov 2012
62
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
cwils02 Gold Member
03rd Nov 2012
78
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
03rd Nov 2012
79
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
RLDubbya Silver Member
03rd Nov 2012
80
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
03rd Nov 2012
85
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
J_Harris Silver Member
03rd Nov 2012
81
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
02nd Nov 2012
70
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
RLDubbya Silver Member
30th Oct 2012
51
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
30th Oct 2012
52
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
lerningoptica
04th Nov 2012
88
                                        Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
cwils02 Gold Member
05th Nov 2012
95
                                   Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
AlexRitchie
02nd Nov 2012
76
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Rassie Silver Member
01st Nov 2012
56
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
01st Nov 2012
57
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
MasterDabber Silver Member
01st Nov 2012
63
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
gfinlayson Silver Member
01st Nov 2012
65
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
briantilley Moderator
01st Nov 2012
66
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Davidpeter1 Silver Member
02nd Nov 2012
75
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
photoman2112
02nd Nov 2012
71
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
MasterDabber Silver Member
02nd Nov 2012
72
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
RSchussel Silver Member
06th Nov 2012
106
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
km6xz Moderator
01st Nov 2012
64
     Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Rassie Silver Member
01st Nov 2012
67
          Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
J_Harris Silver Member
02nd Nov 2012
68
          Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
greenwing Gold Member
02nd Nov 2012
73
          Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Chris Platt Silver Member
03rd Nov 2012
83
          Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
dm1dave Administrator
03rd Nov 2012
86
               Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
kippford Silver Member
06th Nov 2012
107
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
briantilley Moderator
06th Nov 2012
108
                         Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
J_Harris Silver Member
06th Nov 2012
109
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
Rassie Silver Member
06th Nov 2012
104
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
briantilley Moderator
06th Nov 2012
105
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
benmlee
07th Nov 2012
110
Reply message RE: Nikon D7000 Focus Problem
dm1dave Administrator
07th Nov 2012
111

Forums Lobby GET TO KNOW YOUR CAMERA & MASTER IT Nikon D7100, D7000 (Public) topic #21406 Previous topic | Next topic


Take the Nikonians Tour and learn more about being a Nikonian Wiki /FAQ /Help Listen to our MP3 photography radio channels Find anything on Nikon and imaging technology - fast!

Copyright © Nikonians 2000, 2014
All Rights Reserved

Nikonians®, NikoScope® and NikoniansAcademy™ are trademarks owned by Nikonians.org.
Nikon®, Nikonos® and Nikkor® are registered trademarks of Nikon Corporation.