Go to a  "printer friendly" view of this message which allow an easy print Printer-friendly copy Go to the page which allows you to send this topic link and a message to a friend Email this topic to a friend
Forums Lobby GET TO KNOW YOUR CAMERA & MASTER IT Nikon D5300/D5200/D5100/D5000/D3300/D3200/D3100/D3000 (Public) topic #7347
View in linear mode

Subject: "RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review" Previous topic | Next topic
agitater Gold Member Nikonian since 18th Jan 2007Sun 20-Jan-13 04:25 AM
4161 posts Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share on Linkedin    Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this authorClick to view this author's profile
#28. "RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review"
In response to In response to 21


Toronto, CA
          

>As far as the 18-300mm VRII, I have been very disappointed.
>Way too soft @ 300mm which is what I bought it for. My
>70-300VR was much sharper, but doesn't have the range I need
>for Track.

I'm finding the 18-300 VRII quite sharp across a large part of the image circle. Outer edges are softer than the middle at almost every focal length, but that comparative softness is still acceptably sharp.

If you want to see something alarming, turn off the Auto Distortion Control in the Camera menu. That reveals the complex edge distortion at 18-22mm or so and at 250-300mm or so, with in-between focal lengths reasonably well controlled. Without auto distortion control in the camera, the lens would be a real dog for many photographers. ADC is not perfect, but it turns otherwise alarming edge distortion into something either barely noticeable or entirely invisible.

As for overall sharpness in real world shooting, the fact that it's effectively a superzoom means that (VR notwithstanding) photographers have to ensure their handheld and tripod techniques are solid. VR hover, as seen through the viewfinder, can ruin a photographer's technique. I watched a research assistant try the lens in my offices. Mounted on the D5200 and then on a D7000, the research assistant complained that the lens seemed to be backfocusing. So I watched her doing a couple of handheld test shots. What was happening is that she would quiet herself, aim, half-press to lock focus, then almost imperceptibly lean forward just before fully pressing the shutter button. Obviously, she was shifting position while in AF-S mode. I watched her do the exact same almost imperceptible position shift/lean while testing in AF-C, and while doing a focus reaquisition half-press/lift/half-press/release type of action.

I caught myself using shutter speeds of 1/60s while shooting longer than 200mm. Bad practice that is. Basically, VRII is not magic and if anything else in a shooting situation is slightly off (wind gust, unbalanced handheld shooting position, poor grip/hand position on the camera and lens, etc.), the resulting photo will look soft more often than not. I'm just saying that the 18-300 VRII needs regular use and attention to technique in order to produce good-to-excellent shots.

My Photo.Net Gallery
My Nikonians Gallery

Howard Carson

  

Alert Printer-friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

This is a hot, active topic!Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review [View all] , agitater Gold Member, Tue 01-Jan-13 10:56 PM
 
Subject Author Message Date ID
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
John Bertotti Gold Member
02nd Jan 2013
1
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
02nd Jan 2013
2
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
03rd Jan 2013
3
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
John Bertotti Gold Member
03rd Jan 2013
4
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
timpsm Gold Member
03rd Jan 2013
5
     Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
04th Jan 2013
6
          Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
Toby01 Silver Member
04th Jan 2013
7
          Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
John Bertotti Gold Member
04th Jan 2013
8
          Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
04th Jan 2013
9
          Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
timpsm Gold Member
05th Jan 2013
10
          Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
mrginhop Silver Member
08th Jan 2013
11
               Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
timpsm Gold Member
08th Jan 2013
12
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
08th Jan 2013
13
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
jbayston
13th Jan 2013
27
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
eladams629 Gold Member
08th Jan 2013
14
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
09th Jan 2013
15
     Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
eladams629 Gold Member
09th Jan 2013
16
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
pjonesCET Gold Member
10th Jan 2013
17
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
10th Jan 2013
18
     Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
pjonesCET Gold Member
10th Jan 2013
19
     Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
10th Jan 2013
20
          Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
pjonesCET Gold Member
11th Jan 2013
22
               Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
11th Jan 2013
23
               Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
John Bertotti Gold Member
11th Jan 2013
24
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
pjonesCET Gold Member
12th Jan 2013
25
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
13th Jan 2013
26
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
JohnE Nikon Silver Member
01st Mar 2013
33
                         Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
01st Mar 2013
35
                              Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
JohnE Nikon Silver Member
01st Mar 2013
36
     Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
cwils02 Gold Member
11th Jan 2013
21
          Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
20th Jan 2013
28
               Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
Toby01 Silver Member
22nd Jan 2013
29
               Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
22nd Jan 2013
30
                    Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
sde
01st Mar 2013
31
               Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
cwils02 Gold Member
02nd Mar 2013
37
               Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
cwils02 Gold Member
02nd Mar 2013
38
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
sde
01st Mar 2013
32
Reply message RE: Nikon D5200 + Nikkor 18-300 VRII Review
agitater Gold Member
01st Mar 2013
34

Forums Lobby GET TO KNOW YOUR CAMERA & MASTER IT Nikon D5300/D5200/D5100/D5000/D3300/D3200/D3100/D3000 (Public) topic #7347 Previous topic | Next topic


Take the Nikonians Tour and learn more about being a Nikonian Wiki /FAQ /Help Listen to our MP3 photography radio channels Find anything on Nikon and imaging technology - fast!

Copyright © Nikonians 2000, 2014
All Rights Reserved

Nikonians®, NikoScope® and NikoniansAcademy™ are trademarks owned by Nikonians.org.
Nikon®, Nikonos® and Nikkor® are registered trademarks of Nikon Corporation.