- 10-20 3.5 HSM (http://www.sigmaphoto.com/shop/10-20mm-f35-ex-dc-hsm-sigma). Wanted a super wide for my D5100's DX sensor and was in doubt between this and the Tokina 11-16 2.8. (well, there's also the Nikkor 10-24 and I probably should have bought it) The Tokina is well known for being really good and pretty sharp. It is said to be better than this Sigma. And it is 2.8. But does not have a built-in motor so it wouldn't auto-focus on my body. I think Tokina announced a new model with a motor but there's nothing on the shelves yet. This one I don't like too much. I don't know. At least my copy doesn't produce sharp images. Well, it can if I use the sweet spot of 8 or 11 f/stop (above 5.6 is already better) but the overall sense I have is that the image quality is poor.
The first 2 are really good.
>Danny - what Sigma Lenses are you using? >I have a 17-70 which I love and I may try another. >I was curious what you use and like. >
This is the lens I may try. I think I'll rent it first...my 17-70 is not OS, I bought before the OS came out, but it's sharp.
>- 10-20 3.5 HSM >(http://www.sigmaphoto.com/shop/10-20mm-f35-ex-dc-hsm-sigma#. >Wanted a super wide for my D5100's DX sensor and was in doubt >between this and the Tokina 11-16 2.8. #well, there's also the >Nikkor 10-24 and I probably should have bought it# The Tokina >is well known for being really good and pretty sharp. It is >said to be better than this Sigma. And it is 2.8. But does not >have a built-in motor so it wouldn't auto-focus on my body. I >think Tokina announced a new model with a motor but there's >nothing on the shelves yet. >This one I don't like too much. I don't know. At least my copy >doesn't produce sharp images. Well, it can if I use the sweet >spot of 8 or 11 f/stop #above 5.6 is already better) but the >overall sense I have is that the image quality is poor. > >The first 2 are really good. > >>Danny - what Sigma Lenses are you using? >>I have a 17-70 which I love and I may try another. >>I was curious what you use and like. >> >
#7. "RE: Some recent ones with my D5100 and Sigma lenses" In response to Reply # 5
BR
You'll be happy with it for sure.
>>- 17-50 2.8 OS HSM >> > >This is the lens I may try. I think I'll rent it first...my >17-70 is not OS, I bought before the OS came out, but it's >sharp.
#8. "RE: Some recent ones with my D5100 and Sigma lenses" In response to Reply # 7 Wed 04-Jul-12 09:20 PM by BillS52
US
I took this with my Sigma 17-70mm on my D7000.... My youngest son. Gotta love this lens for the price. I posted a larger copy in my gallery. if you double click it you can see how sharp this lens is. I did sharpen slightly in ACR, but not much.
#9. "RE: Some recent ones with my D5100 and Sigma lenses" In response to Reply # 8
BR
Pretty sharp. Good photo!
>I took this with my Sigma 17-70mm on my D7000.... My youngest >son. >Gotta love this lens for the price. >I posted a larger copy in my gallery. if you double click it >you can see how sharp this lens is. I did sharpen slightly in >ACR, but not much. > > > > >
Nikonians®, NikoScope® and NikoniansAcademy™ are trademarks owned by Nikonians.org.
Nikon®, Nikonos® and Nikkor® are registered trademarks of Nikon Corporation.